How do you choose toys for a household with multiple pets?

Having multiple pets can be a joyful but tricky experience, especially when it comes to picking out toys that suit everyone’s preferences. Each pet has its own personality and play style, which can make finding the right toys feel overwhelming. Lately, I’ve noticed my pets are really into one specific toy, but I’m not sure if that’s the best long-term solution for them.

I’ve experimented with different toys that claim to be durable and safe, but they often seem to cater more to one pet than the others. Do you have any suggestions for toys that might be fun for both my energetic dog and my more relaxed cat?

What features do you look for when choosing toys for multiple pets? Are there any favorite brands or types that you really trust? I’d love to hear your thoughts and experiences!